Why Don't All Acoustic Guitars Come with Built-In Electronics Pick-up?
Acoustic guitars are a joy to play and are treasured by countless musicians and hobbyists around the world. However, the inclusion of built-in electronics is a topic that frequently sparks debate among guitar enthusiasts. While some see this feature as a standard and necessary component, others, like myself, find it restrictive and unsatisfactory for professional use. In this article, we will explore the reasons behind why many acoustic guitars do not come with built-in electronics as a standard feature.
My Personal Experience
A couple of years ago, I purchased a 12 string Taylor acoustic guitar. When my friend suggested plugging it in, I was completely unprepared for the rich, transparent sound that emerged. The guitar sounded nearly identical to its acoustic projection, which was a pleasant surprise. This experience led me to question why all acoustic guitars do not come with such built-in electronics.
The Current Trend in Acoustic Guitar Electronics
Fortunately, many modern acoustic guitar makers are beginning to include built-in electronics as standard features. However, from my perspective, these built-in systems often come with their own set of issues, leaving me with a strong preference for the flexibility and control that comes from making my own choice. For instance, Taylor, a renowned brand, outfits almost all of its models with their proprietary Expression System, except for their higher-end models. However, my experience with this system at the NAMM show was less than flattering; within five minutes, I walked away, disenchanted with its performance.
Other Manufacturers and Their Built-In Systems
Martin guitars stand out as a rarity in the acoustic guitar market, as they do not regularly feature built-in electronics. This speaks to their commitment to providing musicians with a customizable experience. However, I have found that even these systems, while perhaps more appealing, often fall short of the sound quality and flexibility that I require as a professional musician.
Why Custom Solutions are Better
For many professional guitarists like myself, a well-designed and properly installed built-in electronics system is a must. I have my stage acoustic guitar built to my specific needs. This guitar includes one of the best onboard systems available, combining both piezo under the bridge and a condenser microphone inside the body. This combination gives me the ability to achieve a truly authentic acoustic sound, with the piezo providing the fundamental attack and the microphone capturing the rich, woody, and full-bodied nuances that define an acoustic guitar.
Conclusion: Customization and Flexibility
While built-in electronics can certainly enhance the versatility of an acoustic guitar, they also come with their own set of constraints and potential drawbacks. As a professional guitarist, I value flexibility and control, which is why I prefer to make my own decisions regarding the amplification of my guitar. If you, too, are a professional musician or someone who values high-quality sound and customization, you might find it worth considering a custom-built guitar with the electronics that suit your specific requirements.
Of course, the choice to include or exclude built-in electronics is ultimately personal. If you do not mind the limitations, go ahead and get the guitar that suits your taste. However, for those seeking the best sonic experience and control, it might be worth considering the opportunity to customize your own guitar. Remember, the sound you get from a custom-built guitar can be truly exceptional, but it also requires a significant investment of time and money.