Which Type of Guitar is Best for Beginners: Folk or Classical?

When starting your guitar journey, it can be overwhelming to choose between a folk or classical guitar. However, there are more options than you might think! This guide will help you understand the pros and cons of each type, and help you decide which one is best for you.

Steel String Acoustic vs. Nylon String Classical Guitars

By ‘folk or classical’ I assume you are referring to steel string acoustic guitars and nylon string classical or Spanish guitars. Both options are excellent for beginners, but they come with their own unique characteristics and challenges.

The Sound Factor

The steel string acoustic guitar offers a brighter, more metallic sound. It is perfect for those who want a full, resonant sound that can project well in various settings. On the other hand, the nylon string classical guitar provides a softer, more mellow sound. This is ideal for those who prefer a more gentle and soothing tone.

The Finger Pain Factor

The softer nylon strings of a classical guitar are gentler on the fingertips, making it easier for beginners to play without causing much pain. Steel strings, however, can be more taxing on the fingertips, causing discomfort until calluses form. This can take several weeks of consistent practice, but the pain is a necessary step towards mastering the instrument.

Choosing the Right Guitar

While both types of guitars are suitable for beginners, the choice ultimately depends on personal preference. The best way to decide is to visit a reputable guitar shop and:

Hold the guitars to get a feel for the difference in weight and handle. Listen to a shop attendant play each type to compare the sounds. Take your time and come back with a clearer idea of which type you prefer.

Remember, the decision should be based on what you are most comfortable with. Both types of guitars require practice, but the comfort and sound should align with your musical aspirations.

Crossover Guitars

If you're not sure which to choose, consider a 'crossover' guitar. These instruments have nylon strings and a narrower neck, making them versatile for both folk music and fingerpicking. Models like the Alvarez RC26HCE are excellent for those who don't want to switch between a wide and narrow neck. These guitars are equipped with features like a cutaway, built-in pickup, and tuner, making them a versatile choice for both classical and folk music.

Steel String Guitars for Volume

For those who prefer the volume and sustain offered by steel string guitars, don't be discouraged by the initial 'hurt factor.' A wider neck steel string guitar, typically measuring 44mm, is an excellent alternative. More experienced players might opt for a larger 50-52mm neck, but some guitars are available with in-between measurements to accommodate different playing styles.

Conclusion

The choice between a folk or classical guitar is highly personal and depends on your musical preferences and playing style. By considering the sound and comfort of each guitar, you can make an informed decision that will enhance your learning journey. Don't let discomfort deter you; with consistent practice, you'll develop calluses and enjoy a more comfortable playing experience. Happy strumming!