What a Metalhead Hates: Common Annoyances and Misunderstandings in the Genre

Being a metalhead comes with its fair share of pet peeves and frustrations. From the external judgments to the internal elitism within the community, there are several aspects that we love to hate. Here, we explore the main annoyances and common misconceptions that plague the metal scene.

Common Annoyances and Misconceptions in the Metal Community

One of the most common annoyances for metalheads is the broad assurances of false metal. This phenomenon occurs when certain sub-genres are deemed false or not true metal. To illustrate this point, think of bands that incorporate hardcore or rap elements into their music. Despite the fusion of genres, some metal elitists will quickly dismiss these bands as not true to metal. This practice is particularly vexing, given that metal itself is already a highly diverse genre with a vast array of sub-genres. From folk to classical, metal has explored and integrated various musical traditions, making it even more diverse. Metalheads also resent the notion of claiming false metal as a means to define or limit the genre. This closes off the potential for new and exciting sounds in music.

External Judgments and Misunderstandings

External judgments form another noxious element in the metal community. Whether it's on social media or in real life, metalheads often encounter non-metal fans who think they know the genre better than those who actually listen to it. These individuals frequently propagate stereotypes, such as the belief that all metal bands are satanic, shouted, or that metal is only for straight white men. These misconceptions are not only cringe-worthy but also deeply hurtful. Let's address some of these common misconceptions:

1. Metal as Satanic

While there are indeed some metal bands that explore Satanic themes, it is a small minority. Many of these themes are for shock value and artistic purposes. The vast majority of metal music deals with a wide range of topics, from war and politics to fantasy and personal introspection. Iron Maiden, for example, has a rich history of songs that go beyond Satanic themes to explore a variety of subjects. The community should own up to the outliers rather than making sweeping generalizations about the entire genre.

2. Shouting or Screaming in Metal

Contrary to popular belief, the majority of metal vocals do not involve screaming or shouting. While some sub-genres like death metal and black metal do employ harsh vocals, the vast majority of metal bands, including famous ones like Van Halen and AC/DC, primarily use growls, screams, or even clean vocals. This misconception is often based on a narrow sample of music, possibly from melodic death metal or metalcore bands. The diversity and range of metal music should be recognized and respected.

3. Metalhead Violence and Victimhood

Metalheads are no more likely to be violent than any other demographic. In fact, some individuals within the metal community have encountered violence due to their differences. The stereotype that metalheads are automatically violent is unjust and harmful. Real instances, like the Sophie Lancaster case, highlight the violence faced by those who are different, including metalheads. While it's true that some individuals within the metal community have engaged in violence, it is more often the case that metalheads are the victims of such acts.

The idea that metalheads always play their music too loud is another misconception. In reality, the loudness of metal music is a natural result of its genre. However, this doesn't mean that metalheads play their music loudly to be disruptive. In urban settings, it's more likely to hear a car with its stereo blasting at an inappropriately loud volume, yet non-metal fans would immediately blame metal for this. The reality is that the community respects the quiet and often appreciates the subtleties of metal music. It's an issue of cultural awareness and understanding.

The idea that metal is exclusively for straight white men is simply false. The metal scene is comprised of women, people of color, and individuals from diverse backgrounds. Bands like Girlschool, Lovebites, and Akercocke have proven that metal can be enjoyed and performed by anyone regardless of their gender or ethnicity. Metal is a genre that welcomes diversity and inclusivity, reflecting the real world in its complexity.

Breaking Down Metal Elitism

Internal to the metal community, the concept of elitism is a significant source of conflict. Some individuals believe there is a hierarchy of quality within the genre, assigning names like "true metal" and "false metal" based on their own preferences. This elitism often extends to websites like Encyclopaedia Metallum, which can exacerbate the issue. The diversity of metal is vast, and every fan’s tastes are valid. Embracing this diversity and recognizing that there is no true or false metal allows for a more inclusive and welcoming community.

Conclusion

Being a metalhead is about enjoying and loving the music, not about adhering to specific rules or labels. The metal community is diverse and rich, with a wide array of sub-genres and themes. External judgments and internal elitism only serve to limit the potential of the genre and frustrate the passionate fans who cherish the music. By breaking down these barriers and embracing the diversity and inclusivity of metal, we can foster a more positive and vibrant community.