What Was It Like to Be in a Band with John Fogerty of Creedence Clearwater Revival?
Creedence Clearwater Revival (CCR) is renowned for its powerful music and dynamic performances. Among its members, John Fogerty looms large, not just musically but also in terms of leadership. If Fogerty had emerged 10 years later, the music industry might look different, with his band structured much like those of contemporaries such as Tom Petty, Bruce Springsteen, and Bob Seger. These artists, wherein the singer-songwriter held the reins, often had smoother and more successful careers.
The journey of CCR was considerably more complex. Initially, John's brother Tom was the band leader under the moniker Tommy Fogerty and the Blue Velvets. In the transition to the Golliwogs, Tom remained the primary lead singer. An album by the Golliwogs highlights the distinct vocal styles of Tom and John, with Tom's voice resonating a different arc and touch compared to John's.
When CCR emerged, the atmosphere shifted entirely. It was unequivocally the John Fogerty Show. From songwriting to production and arrangement, recruitment to overdubbing, John took charge. While the other band members were undoubtedly talented musicians, their roles were diminished. They were essentially riding on John's work.
However, this structure brought discomfort. For Tom, especially, who had to watch his younger brother wield such immense control, feelings of jealousy likely simmered. These emotionally charged dynamics culminated in Tom's eventual departure from the band. Clifford and Cook did contribute a handful of songs to the final CCR studio album, Mercedes Benz, yet their efforts were overshadowed by the prevailing spotlight on John.
The music environment, described as "stifling", was a reflection of the band's divided attention. At the apex of their popularity, they were among the greatest rock and roll bands in the world, yet the focus was almost exclusively on John. Over 50 years later, John still garners almost all the attention, a testament to his enduring impact on the band and the music industry.
Post-Band Animosity
Irritation and ill will have been the hallmarks of the band members' post-CRR existence. The aftermath pales in comparison to the era of band unity. Even when Fogerty refused to perform with the surviving members at the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame ceremony, Cook and Clifford were left in the audience. This was an insult to them, leaving them feeling snubbed. The bitter feelings between them have not diminished over time.
Conclusion
Being in a band with John Fogerty during his heyday was a mix of honors and hardship. The stifling focus on him meant that other members had to struggle for recognition despite their talent. The legacy of CCR remains undeniably that of John Fogerty, but it's a legacy marred by internal strife and lasting animosity among the surviving members.
Keywords: Creedence Clearwater Revival, John Fogerty, Stifling Music Environment