Was Pete Best or Ringo Starr the Worse Drummer in The Beatles?
The iconic music group, The Beatles, featured four incredible musicians, each contributing uniquely to the band's success. Among them were two talented drummers: Pete Best and Ringo Starr. Fans often debate which of these two drummers was the lesser of the two. In this article, we will explore the reasons behind the decision to replace Pete Best and why Ringo Starr ultimately became the iconic drummer of the Beatles.
The Decision to Replace Pete Best
When Brian Epstein, the band's manager, and George Martin, the new record producer, insisted on the replacement of Pete Best, it became clear that he was not up to the task as a professional drummer for the band's level of musicianship.
Pete Best's Limitations
It's no secret that Pete Best had plateaued in his drumming skills by the time he was 20, while Paul McCartney, John Lennon, and George Harrison were still growing as musicians at a rapid rate. One of the most significant issues with Pete was his inability to keep a consistent tempo, a fundamental job requirement for any drummer.
Listen to the three versions of 'Love Me Do' where you can hear Pete Best, Andy White, and Ringo Starr performing. The difference is stark. While Pete's unsteady rhythm is evident, the professional touch of Andy White and the polished timing of Ringo Starr are clear. Pay particular attention to the tempo. Pete's inconsistent timing is a hallmark of his drumming style.
The Transition from Amateur to Professional
Pete Best was, in many ways, an amateur drummer. In fact, his mother gave him a drum set to practice, and he found a spare room to do so. In contrast, Ringo Starr was more experienced and professional, which is why he was chosen as Pete Best's replacement.
Initially, studio personnel did not consider Ringo as a 'real' drummer. However, his skills improved significantly, and he eventually became an integral part of the Beatles' dynamic as a drummer.
The Beatles' Perspective
The boys in the band, including Ringo Starr himself, knew that Pete's drumming was lacking. They were actively seeking an excuse to replace him. This decision was not made lightly, and it was clear that Pete needed to improve significantly to keep up with the rest of the band and their rapid evolution.
Historical Context and Impact
The replacement of Pete Best with Ringo Starr marked an important chapter in The Beatles' history. Pete's departure allowed the band to achieve a more polished sound, but it also meant that a part of the band's original history was lost. However, it ultimately contributed to the band's enduring legacy and the iconic status of Ringo Starr.
Conclusion
While Pete Best had his time with the Beatles, his drumming skills did not meet the standards required for one of the greatest music acts of all time. Ringo Starr's arrival marked a significant improvement in the band's sound and solidified his place as the drummer of The Beatles, contributing to the band's continued success and global impact.