Can Upright Bass Players Play Electric Bass?

In the world of bass playing, versatility is key. Many bassists find themselves transitioning between different types of basses, whether they are upright bass players switching to electric or vice versa. This article will explore the nuances of this transition, providing valuable insights for bassists of all skill levels.

Starting Points and Transitions

Can upright bass players play electric bass? The answer largely depends on their starting point and what they want to achieve. If a bassist started on the upright bass and that’s what they know, they can play the electric without much trouble. However, if the bassist started on a bass guitar, they will need to make some adjustments to adapt to the upright.

Adapting to the Upright Bass

For those transitioning from the bass guitar to the upright bass, a few key adjustments are necessary. One of the most significant challenges is the lack of frets on the upright bass. This means that the positions for the notes are more spread out, requiring a firmer touch with the left hand to play in tune. Additionally, the weak little finger that many bass guitar players don’t use becomes an essential tool on the upright bass, requiring a new technique of playing with fingers 1, 2, 3, and 4.

Playing Techniques

Upright bass players have the advantage of being familiar with classical playing techniques such as pizzicato (plucking the strings with the fingers), which can be applied to jazz and bluegrass music as well. While playing with the bow (arco) on an upright bass is a skill that needs to be learned, electric bassists can find it easier to adopt this technique, especially if they’ve developed a strong sense of touch and control.

The Transition from Electric to Upright

Conversely, an upright player can easily adapt to electric play, as the open strings and the order of notes are the same. However, an electric bass player will need to learn some new skills when transitioning to the upright, particularly concerning arco playing.

From Electric to Double Bass

Some bassists may find themselves transitioning from a double bass to an electric bass. This is especially true when considering the demands of playing with the bow (arco) versus plucking the strings (pizzicato).

Personal Experience: An Electric Bassist to an Upright Bassist

I play both electric guitar-style and stand-up bass, and I have been told that I am unusual; most bassists typically play one or the other. My journey from double bass to electric bass reflects a natural progression for many musicians.

Transitioning with Talent and Determination

My 15-year-old son took an even more extensive journey, transitioning from electric bass to double bass. Initially competent on electric bass, he was asked to play in the pit for The Sound of Music at school. He then decided that the double bass was the better instrument for those dots (notation) and took to it very readily. This transition was possible because he has both talent and determination.

Adjustments and Adaptations

Initially, he faced an ordeal to find a half-size double bass, now equipped with a piezo pickup. His education in playing the upright bass came from his bass teacher and consistent hard work over a couple of months. The transition from electric bass to double bass, particularly with regard to arco bowing, presented a new set of skills that he managed to master well.

Conclusion

The ability to play both upright and electric basses is a testament to the versatility of bass players. Whether a bassist is transitioning from one type of bass to the other, the key to success lies in adapting to the unique characteristics and techniques of each instrument. With the right approach and practice, the transition can be seamless, enhancing the bassist’s skill set and expanding their musical horizons.