The Triviality of the Best Songwriter Question in The Beatles
When it comes to The Beatles, a band that defined the sound and sentiment of an entire generation, the question of who was the best songwriter often arises. However, attributing the finest songwriting skills to any one member is an oversimplification of a uniquely collaborative process that spanned the group's illustrious career.
The Collaborative Genesis of Beatle Songs
The early period songs of Lennon and McCartney display the undeniable influences of Buddy Holly, Chuck Berry, the Everly Brothers, and rockabilly. These artists left indelible marks on the fabric of their songs, reflecting the era's musical landscape. Despite these external influences, the underlying collaborative spirit was clear, with John Lennon often setting the tone and form, predominantly in the AABA structure.
Paul and John: The Songwriting Duo
Paul and John were the primary composers of most of the Beatles' songs, a practice that led to the moniker "Lennon/McCartney" being used consistently. Nonetheless, the split between their contributions is often murky, as the acknowledgment of their collaborative efforts blurred the lines between individual songwriting.
John's Slight Edge in Songwriting
Despite the collaborative nature, John Lennon wrote or co-wrote slightly more songs than Paul McCartney. This subtle edge, however, does not diminish the quality of Paul's songs, which often gained more covers, indicating their wide popularity. Notably, in a comparative conversation, Paul Simon, a renowned songwriter in his own right, ranked himself as a "level 2" songwriter, placing Bob Dylan and John Lennon at the same level. He considered Irving Berlin and Paul McCartney as "level 1" writers, suggesting the vast number of classics they produced.
Personal Talents and Contributions
Judging the best songwriter in The Beatles is inherently subjective. George Martin, the legendary producer, once opined that Paul McCartney was the most naturally talented musician, finding it easy to write melodies. Conversely, John Lennon excelled at writing lyrics. Both, however, were capable of composing exceptional melodies and lyrics, shattering any notion that one was superior to the other. George Harrison, a key member of the band, also made his mark on the group's legacy. His song "Here Comes the Sun" remains one of the most downloaded Beatles tracks, underscoring the depth and breadth of talent within the band.
Conclusion: The Rich Heritage of The Beatles
The Beatles' contributions to music are immeasurable, and labeling one songwriter as the best is far from being a definitive answer. Each member brought unique strengths to the group, collectively creating a catalogue of timeless songs that continue to resonate with listeners today. The collaborative spirit and individual talents of John, Paul, and George Harrison make The Beatles a musical masterpiece unparalleled in its era.