Understanding the Misunderstandings Behind the Hatred towards The Monkees
The Monkees, a beloved music act from the 1960s, have undergone a long-standing period of criticism and disdain. This article explores the reasons behind the initial hostility, dispels common misconceptions, and celebrates their unique contributions to the rock and roll genre.
The Fabrication Myth
The Monkees are often dismissed as a manufactured group, lacking authenticity and musical talent. This perception, however, is largely fueled by a combination of timing, contextual factors, and the evolving nature of the music industry during their era. Critics and other bands of the time often attacked the Monkees due to their assembly-line approach, which was a product of the television industry's demand for content rather than the pure passion for music.
Artistic Evolution and Snobbery
In the early 1960s, rock music began to be taken more seriously by critics, and groups like The Beatles, The Rolling Stones, and Bob Dylan were reshaping the genre from juvenile pop music into a legitimate art form. This shift in perception played a significant role in the Monkees' initial reception, as their assembly-line production model was seen as frivolous and detracted from the perceived seriousness of rock music.
Behind the Scenes: Don Kirshner and the Brill Building
The Monkees' lack of instrument-playing initially stemmed from the insistence of Don Kirshner, who saw the group as primarily a television act. Despite the Brill Building songwriters being prominent figures in the industry, the focus was on crafting melodies and lyrics rather than fostering personal expression through music. However, as The Monkees evolved, they began to assert control over their own music and production. For instance, Michael Nesmith, a talented songwriter and musician, worked to prove the group's capabilities by securing lead guitar work and inspiring others to contribute more to the band's sound.
Renouncing the Stereotypes
In 1967, Michael Nesmith addressed these criticisms in a Hollywood Reporter interview, admitting that the group was manufactured and acknowledging a lack of control over their output. While his honesty was commendable, it provided ammunition for detractors who continued to treat the band with scorn. Despite this, the Monkees eventually proved their worth through innovative and artistic contributions to rock music.
Challenging the Status Quo
Their journey from a television act to a breakthrough band in the music industry is a testament to their resilience and determination. The Monkees broke away from the traditional model of the music industry, effectively stealing fire from the Establishment. Their success in these revolutionary changes paved the way for future acts and demonstrated the power of collaboration and innovation within the industry.
Art and Resilience
Among the most celebrated Monkees songs is I’ll Be Back Up on My Feet, which captures the spirit of their journey and resilience. This piece serves as a reminder that sometimes, the most meaningful achievements come from challenging preconceived notions and pushing boundaries.
Post-American Popularity
Fifty-plus years later, such criticisms have largely faded, and The Monkees are now recognized as the underrated talent that they always were. While a handful of critics still hold onto elitist views, the broader public acknowledges the band's contributions to rock and roll. Critics like Jann Wenner, the former head of Rolling Stone magazine, have even excluded the Monkees from the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, perpetuating the idea that they don't fit into the self-congratulatory narrative of rock history.
Conclusion
The founding and evolution of The Monkees offer a rich tapestry of artistic and cultural change. Despite initial skepticism and hostility, they managed to adapt and thrive, challenging the status quo and leaving a lasting impact on the landscape of rock and roll music.