The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best Guitar Pick Size and Thickness

Guitarists often face the question: what is the best size and thickness of a guitar pick to use? It's a highly personal and subjective choice that can significantly impact your playing style and tone. In this guide, we will explore different pick sizes and thicknesses, share insights from experienced guitar players, and provide tips on how to find the perfect pick for your needs.

Personal Preferences and Experiences

Many guitarists, like myself, develop a preference for a particular pick size and thickness over time. I've been using Jim Dunlop 1mm picks for the last few decades, and they have become a staple in my playing. These picks offer a great balance between flexibility and rigidity, and they have the added benefit of providing a good grip between the thumb and forefinger. Their widespread availability also makes them convenient for any guitarist to use.

However, your pick choice might be quite different. My daughter-in-law gave me a stone pick a couple of years ago, and, although it was an unusual choice, it worked fine for me. Pick size and thickness are deeply personal preferences, and what feels right for one guitarist might not suit another.

Tips for New Guitarists

For beginners, it's often recommended to start with thinner picks. Thinner picks typically provide a brighter tone and are easier to manipulate, making them a good choice for beginners who are still learning to control their playing. However, as you become more advanced, you might find that thicker picks offer better control and a deeper, more nuanced tone.

Experimenting with different picks is the best way to find your ideal pick. If you're a student or just starting, consider buying a variety pack of picks. This will allow you to explore different sizes and materials, and you can find the pick that suits your playing style the best.

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Pick

When choosing a pick, several factors can influence your decision. The pick's size, thickness, and even material can affect the tone and attack of your playing. Common pick materials include nylon, plastic, and metal, each offering a unique sound and feel.

For example, Fender medium 351 picks are widely regarded as having a good balance of tone and playability. The DAndrea version of these picks is often praised for providing a slightly more vibrant and dynamic sound. However, the best pick for you is ultimately determined by your personal taste and playing style.

Buying Tips and Experimentation

When shopping for guitar picks, it's important to remember that they are relatively inexpensive, so don't hesitate to try different ones. Start with a variety pack and experiment until you find the pick that feels right to you. Here are a few tips:

Try different sizes and thicknesses. A thicker pick can create a deeper tone with more overtones, while a thinner pick will produce a brighter, more defined sound. Feel the pick in your hand. The material and thickness should provide a comfortable and manageable grip. Determine your preferred grip. Some players prefer a grip that allows for precise control, while others might prefer a grip that provides a bit more flexibility.

Remember, the ultimate goal is to find a pick that enhances your playing experience and helps you achieve the sound you want. Each guitarist must decide what they prefer based on their unique playing style and personal taste.

Happy playing!