The Secret Drumming History Behind The Beatles’ ‘Love Me Do’
Generations of Beatles fans are familiar with the iconic debut single 'Love Me Do.' But for the first time, let's delve into the inning that few have known - the secret drumming history behind the song. Holding the key are the drum sessions with Andy White, Ringo Starr, and how they shaped the recorded hits that changed the music landscape.
Andy White and the Surprising Drumming Opportunity
During their original EMI session, George Martin had his doubts about the drumming skills of Pete Best, leading to his firing and the addition of Ringo Starr as a replacement. Unaware of this personnel change, Martin had booked a session drummer, Andy White, for the next session in September.
When the band arrived with Ringo Starr, Martin made it clear that White would drum on the track as he was paid for, leaving Ringo off the initial session. However, a compromise was reached, leading to a second session where Starr would drum on one version, and White on the other. This practice gave Martin a chance to assess Ringo's abilities in a controlled environment.
Both Drummers Made It to Disc
The final decision revealed that Ringo Starr's drumming proved to be the way forward, and thus his version was chosen for the release and the Beatles' debut album. However, records show that both drummer versions of 'Love Me Do' were released in the UK. A simple yet effective way to differentiate between the two is by listening for an additional tambourine during the song. If it's not heard, it was Ringo on drums; if it is, it's thanks to Andy White.
Andy White’s Session Drumming on 'Love Me Do'
The session with Andy White on drums took place on October 5, 1962, and it marked the release of a different version of 'Love Me Do.' This version has a distinct feel, thanks to White's drumming. And it wasn't just a one-time effort; Andy's skills and style had impressed Martin, who deemed White to be the right choice for the recorded hit.
Andy White is widely recognized as an excellent drummer, and his session work with the Beatles left a lasting impact. While Ringo Starr later became the drummer of choice, Andy's contribution to the album and single version of 'Love Me Do' showcased his unique musical prowess and provided an incomparable detail in the history of rock.
Comparisons and Context
Below are comparative recordings of 'Love Me Do' showcasing the differences in drumming styles:
The Grey Area: Love Me Do with Pete Best
Comparing this version, you can still hear the unique qualities Pete Best brought to the table but falls a bit short compared to the eventual releases.
The Ringo Starr Version
This was the version that stuck and became the definitive recording many know and love. It's a testament to Ringo's drumming abilities even at this early point in his career.
Love Me Do with Andy White
The session with Andy White, while not chosen as the final version, offered a distinct and powerful drum sound that is still celebrated for its unique flair.
Love Me Do with Ringo ‘RJ’
This more recent version is not a part of the original recording but highlights how Ringo's drumming has matured over the years.
The Takeaway
The story of 'Love Me Do' reflects the early days of the Beatles, showcasing the versatility and evolution of their music, especially in terms of their drumming. Andy White's session drumming on 'Love Me Do' stands as a testament to the enduring quality of the Beatles' recordings and the skilled hands behind them.
While the ultimate decision was to stick with Ringo Starr, the contributions of session drummers like Andy White shaped the sound and impact of the Beatles. Their inclusion in the history of rock music remains a fascinating and intricate chapter.