The Evolution of Jam Band Success: Why No Band Has Become ‘The Next Phish'
Since its formation, Phish has captured the hearts and minds of countless music enthusiasts over the past decades. Yet, time and time again, fans and musicians alike have asked, 'Is there a next Phish?' This question intrigued many, leading to the birth of numerous bands and musicians labeled as such, yet none have truly matched Phish's legendary status.
Unique Aspects of Phish
Phish stands apart from its contemporaries and predecessors. Much like the Grateful Dead, Phish is a unique amalgamation of musical styles and structures that cannot be replicated. Each band practitioner has its ingredients and influences, but none can reproduce the exact blend that has allowed Phish to thrive.
Trying to find the 'next Phish' is akin to asking who is the next 'your mom' or 'you.' These are unique individuals and entities, and thus, the search can be misleading. Embrace the music you love and stop chasing the elusive 'next band.'
Early 90s: Contemporaries Not Successors
During the early 90s, several bands emerged that were collectively labeled as 'jam bands,' but none have captured the massive audience that Phish managed to. Bands like Spin Doctors, Blues Traveler, Rusted Root, and Dave Matthews Band were considered influential in the alternative rock scene. They were more radio-friendly and managed to generate hit singles, something Phish did not achieve until their later years. Dave Matthews Band (DBMB) is the closest to landing the same level of success as Phish, headlining major amphitheaters and regularly playing sold-out events.
Late 90s-2000s: Inspires but Lacks, Even with Festivals
The late 90s to the 2000s saw a rise in bands that were inspired by Phish or shared audiences. Groups like The Disco Biscuits, The String Cheese Incident, moe., and Umphrey's McGee emerged during this time and managed to gain sizable fan bases. However, none of these bands have managed to play Madison Square Garden, let alone host a 60,000 fan festival. Phish's return in 2009 after a four-year hiatus solidified this.
Festivals like Bonnaroo provided a platform for smaller bands to thrive, allowing them to bypass the major venue gigs. These festivals enabled bands to maintain profitability and success without needing to headline large arenas. While these festivals supported Phish and the emerging bands, the comparison to Phish's sustained success in arenas like Madison Square Garden remains a distant memory.
2010s-Early 2020s: Modern Potential ‘Next Phish’
In the 2010s and early 2020s, more bands began to emerge with the potential to become the 'next Phish.' Bands like Twiddle, Spafford, and Goose excited many with their energy and creativity. However, Twiddle seems to have hit a plateau in terms of theatrical performances and festivals, while Goose's growth has slowed down due to multiple drummer changes. Beachwood Sparks' collaboration with Phish and their success in arenas like Mohegan Sun have also added to the debate.
Another interesting artist to watch, Billy Strings, has shown potential. As a bluegrass guitarist with a unique style, he has the potential to reach larger audiences. However, only time will tell if he can sustain this growth and regularly play major venues.
Grateful Dead Legacy and Phish Side Projects
Finally, it is worth noting the ongoing legacy of the Grateful Dead and Phish. Band members of the Grateful Dead have continued playing their music through cover bands like The Dead Furthur and Dead and Company. Joe Russo’s Almost Dead also continues to grow, playing in larger venues including SPAC in 2022. Phish's side projects, like Trey Anastasio Band, have also remained theater and festival-driven, with no immediate plans to move to larger venues.
Phish's unique sound and live performance style have made it an irreplaceable part of the music scene. However, the passion and energy of bands like Twiddle, Goose, and others remind us that the spirit of innovation and community remains alive in the music industry.
So, whether you are a fan of Phish, Grateful Dead, or any of the bands discussed here, it's important to appreciate the unique journey and experiences each brings. The music industry is ever-evolving, and the search for the 'next Phish' can be both nostalgic and rewarding.