The Disadvantages of Using Thick Picks While Playing the Guitar
Choosing the right guitar pick (picks) can be a deeply personal experience, much like your choice in guitar. Some guitarists opt for heavy picks (thick picks), while others prefer thin picks. The reasons behind this choice vary as much as the individual playing. In this article, we will explore some of the potential disadvantages of using thick picks, particularly in terms of sound articulation and playing comfort.
Hello Hello
Heavy Sound - Perhaps you've noticed a difference in the sound produced by thick picks versus thinner ones. Thicker picks, such as those with a thickness of 1.5 mm (or even 1.2 mm depending on the material), can deliver a darker and fuller sound. However, for those who prefer a more articulated and vibrant tone, this can be a drawback.
When I played with a medium pick, I found that the sound lacked a certain articulation, leading me to switch to a thinner 1.2 mm pick. The Planet Waves [D'Addario] black 1.5 mm pick can offer a darker yet well-controlled sound. For me, a more articulate feel is provided by a 1.2 mm pick, which allows for precise string attacks and a clear tone.
Interestingly, some Fender type picks are known for their versatility. The Dunlop Gator Grips at 1.5 mm can feel particularly rubbery and wax-like, surprisingly bright even when they might be expected to be dull and dark. Ultimately, what you prefer is a matter of personal preference.
Evolution of Pick Choice
Many guitarists begin with extremely thin picks, often those with a thickness of around 0.5 mm. These picks are easier to manipulate and are forgiving for beginner players. As players improve their finger dexterity and technique, they often move on to thicker picks. This transition not only helps in developing finger control but also in targeting the right strings with precision.
However, as we delve deeper into the nuances of playing, we realize that different picks can produce different sounds, even at the same thickness. Materials and composition play significant roles. Some players might switch to a 1.0 to 1.2 mm pick for slap-style playing with palm muting, whereas others might opt for thinner picks for tremolo picking. The choice ultimately depends on the style of music being played and the desired sound.
Personal Comfort and Sound Quality
What works for one player may not work for another. I prefer picks that are moderately heavy with a rounded tip. This allows me to glide over the strings more accurately and with greater speed than I could with thinner picks with sharp tips. However, it is essential to note that this method of playing is not universal. Many players might disagree and prefer different pick types.
The bottom line is to use the pick that suits your playing style and produces the best tone. Not everyone can or should play with a very heavy pick. Even professional guitarists with advanced skills have their preferences, and there are no hard and fast rules. It's important to consider that genuine tortoiseshell picks were considered the pinnacle of quality, although they are now prohibited due to conservation efforts. Modern alternatives offer similar benefits but with added environmental considerations.
Ultimately, the choice of a thick pick is a matter of personal preference and experimentation. It's recommended to try different types to find what works best for you. Whether you're a beginner or an experienced player, the goal is to strike the perfect balance between sound and comfort, and to enjoy the process of exploring different methods of playing the guitar.