The Debate Over Australia’s National Anthem: Should 'Advance Australia Fair' Be Replaced?
Is it time for Australia to abandon 'Advance Australia Fair' as its national anthem? The debate is heating up with opinions from many sides, especially considering the term 'girt by sea,' which may sound outdated in today's context. In this article, we explore the current state of the debate, the qualities of the current anthem, and suggestions for an alternative anthem.
Current State of the National Anthem Debate
Many Australians, including New Zealanders, have expressed their views on whether 'Advance Australia Fair' should be given up for another song. While some find the 'girt by sea' line a bit outdated, the tune remains the essence of the anthem, fit for celebrations and sporting events.
Ranking of National Anthems
A New Zealander, reflecting on the international quality of national anthems, has compiled a list of what might be considered the best. While the ranking is subjective, it sheds light on different perspectives:
Chilean National Anthem: Sung with gusto, it is a standout anthem. South African National Anthem: A multi-language anthem that still strikes a resonating chord. French National Anthem: A timeless classic that needs to be recognized. Ireland’s Call: A powerful anthem often used in Irish unity. Samoan Anthem: A very moving testament to national pride. Welsh National Anthem: A song with deep emotional appeal. Australian National Anthem: Also up there in the rankings due to its stirring tune. New Zealand Anthem Sung in Maori: A unique and delightful addition, though it pales in comparison to the Kiwi anthem. Brazilian National Anthem: A vibrant and lively representation of Latin culture. Japanese National Anthem: One of the most beautiful from the Asian region.Recommendations for a New National Anthem
Given the ongoing debate and interest, some have suggested alternate national anthems. One New Zealander suggests that 'Am I Not Australian' by Bruce Woodley of The Seekers and Dobe Newton of The Bushwackers could be a fitting choice. The song was featured in local pop culture and has a strong connection to Australian identity.
Final Thoughts
While opinions may differ, it's clear that the current anthem, 'Advance Australia Fair,' is not perfect. The suggestion to rewrite the 'girt by sea' line is widely agreed upon. Over the next few years, the Australian government and society will continue to grapple with this choice, examining what best represents the nation's values and cultural identity.
One thing is certain: the national anthem holds a special place in the hearts of many Australians. The quest for a new anthem is not just about changing the lyrics but about celebrating and expressing national pride in a way that resonates with modern Australia.