Mick Taylor vs. Keith Richards: Who is Better on the Electric Guitar for The Rolling Stones?

Mick Taylor and Keith Richards, both legendary guitarists, contributed uniquely to the iconic band, The Rolling Stones. Mick was known for his versatility, particularly taking on the lead guitar role, while Keith dominated the rhythm guitar section. However, there are instances when each guitarist strayed from their usual roles. This article explores their skills, showcasing examples from their discography to determine who might be the better guitarist for the two roles in the band.

Role Definitions

In the early days with Mick Taylor, the divide between rhythm and lead guitar in The Rolling Stones was more pronounced. Mick primarily handled lead duties, leaving Keith to focus on rhythm. They complemented each other well, with moments when Keith played lead and Mick provided rhythm support. This dynamic was crucial to the band's success.

Mick Taylor: An Accomplished Lead Guitarist

Undoubtedly, Mick Taylor demonstrated more proficiency and fluidity as a soloist. Both Keith Richards and Ronnie Wood have endorsed this. Taylor's exceptional skills in electric blues marked him as one of the best in the world. His contributions to the band's sound were pivotal and memorable.

Keith Richards: The Rhythm Guitar Maestro

Though Mick excelled in the lead role, Keith was the master of crafting rhythm parts that went beyond simple chordal accompaniment. Meticulous in his writing, Keith's rhythm work was more than just a foundation; it often integrated lead licks that added depth and complexity to the music.

Ronnie Wood: The Equally Matched Guitarist

Ronnie Wood shares a similar skill set with both Mick and Keith. While Wood is considered a better lead player, this skill parity indicates a high level of competence from all three guitarists. They often interwove their guitar parts, creating a unique blend of rhythm and lead.

Interplay and Weaving

The interplay between Mick and Keith was particularly noteworthy. They “wove” their guitars together with creativity akin to other legendary guitar duos. This was evident in their performances and recordings. An example is the song “Can’t You Hear Me Knocking” from Sticky Fingers.

“Can’t You Hear Me Knocking” - A Showcase of Guitar Skills

The song “Can’t You Hear Me Knocking” from “Sticky Fingers” exemplifies the distinct styles of Mick and Keith. Keith plays the opening riff, layering rhythm parts with Chuck Berry influences and intricate rhythmic figures to support the vocal line. Mick's rhythm section, played on the second verse, adds a solid, funk-infused texture. In the jam section, Mick’s fluid solo, reminiscent of Carlos Santana, showcases his improvisational abilities, which both Keith and the band couldn't replicate.

Keith accompanies Mick’s solo with a subtle yet foundational rhythm, ensuring it aligns with Bobby Keys’ saxophone solo. This interplay demonstrates the contrast between their roles but also highlights their complementary skills.

Conclusion

While Mick Taylor certainly has his strengths as a lead guitarist, the band's success also benefited significantly from Keith Richards' rhythm expertise. Both guitarists brought unparalleled talent to The Rolling Stones, but their roles were clearly defined yet flexible. Keith's groovy riffs, like “Can’t You Hear Me Knocking,” showcased his depth as a rhythm player, making him an essential part of the band's sound. Nonetheless, Mick's acclaimed improvisational skills and lead work cannot be understated, making both guitarists integral to the band's legendary status.