Is the 80s Rock/Pop Better than the 90s? A Retrospective Comparison

While many argue that current music is homogenized and lacking in talent, the 1980s and 1990s were two impactful decades for rock and pop music. This article delves into the era by exploring why the 80s may be considered superior to the 90s in terms of talent and variety, despite the latter's enduring legacy.

Introduction to the Debate

Often, modern music is criticized for its lack of originality and quality. In this context, some music fans nostalgically recall the 1980s, considering it a golden age of music. They argue that the 90s music lacks the caliber and diversity of the 80s. However, this article suggests that the 90s were not entirely without merit, particularly in the early years.

The 1980s: A Decade of Talent and Variety

Arguably, the 1980s were a breeding ground for musical talent with a wide variety of genres and styles. The advent of MTV in 1981 marked a significant shift in how music was consumed, introducing audiences to a wealth of new bands and artists.

MTV Launch and New Romanticism

The launch of MTV brought bands like Duran Duran, The Thompson Twins, Eurythmics, Culture Club, and during the New Romanticism movement, to the forefront. These bands, often associated with high fashion and flamboyant styles, captivated audiences with their unique sounds and visual aesthetics.

Bar Bands and College Radio

Other notable bands included glorified bar bands like Huey Lewis and the News, Mr. Mister, John Mellencamp, and Loverboy. These groups, while perhaps not as glamorous, nevertheless provided catchy and versatile music that resonated with listeners. College radio further expanded the music scene, introducing listeners to a range of genres, including indie and alternative rock from bands like R.E.M., Husker Du, The Minutemen, and The Cure.

Urban Music and Pop Dynamo

The 1980s also saw the rise of urban music, driven by artists such as Grandmaster Flash, Run DMC, LL Cool J, and Kool Moe Dee. These artists introduced rap and hip hop into the mainstream, paving the way for future generations of performers.

Pop and Dance Sensation

Mainstream pop and dance music were dominated by icons like Michael Jackson, Madonna, Prince, and Cyndi Lauper. These artists' legacies continue to influence contemporary music, and their hits remain popular even today.

Rock in the Sunset Strip

The Sunset Strip in Los Angeles became a hub for rock music, launching the careers of iconic bands such as Motley Crue, Ratt, Poison, and Dokken. These groups contributed to the hard rock and glam metal scenes of the 1980s, influencing a generation of musicians.

Bay Area Scene

San Francisco hosted its own scene, featuring underground bands like Metallica, Slayer, Megadeth, and Exodus. These groups became the forces behind the thrash metal movement and continue to be influential in the rock world.

Is the 1990s Overrated?

Although the 1980s were remarkable, some argue that the 1990s had their merits, especially in the early years. While there are fewer standout hits, the diversity of the decade leads to a mixed legacy.

Early 90s Comparisons

Some music fans still enjoy parts of the 90s, particularly the early years. While many 90s music hits might not compare to their 80s counterparts, the decade contributed significantly to the alternative rock scene, with bands such as The Pixies, Red Hot Chili Peppers, Jane’s Addiction, and Sonic Youth.

Declining Quality in the Late 90s

The late 90s saw a decline in the quality and variety of music, with many listeners feeling that the focus shifted more towards the people behind the music and their drama. Reality TV played a significant role in this shift, making personal and often trivial matters the center of attention, often at the expense of the music itself.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while the 1980s are often hailed as the golden age of rock and pop music, the 1990s cannot be entirely dismissed. Both decades have their distinct merits and contributions to the world of music. The choice between the two can often come down to personal preference and which era one holds dear in their heart.