Is Standard Tuning the Best Way to Finger Open Chords?

When it comes to the question of whether standard tuning is the best way to finger open chords, the answer is often highly subjective. Standard tuning, with its classic EADGBE set, has been the standard for centuries, having 'won' this title through natural selection for a reason.

The Evolution of Standard Tuning

Standard tuning has been cultivated and preserved over hundreds of years by countless musicians. The reason for its prominence is evident: it makes it easier for guitarists to play the root chord with open strings and simplifies the fingering process for almost every other chord. This is why most songs and guitar charts are written in standard tuning.

The Limits of Open Tunings

While open tunings, such as drop D or DADGAD, are fantastic for playing extended chords (chords with 9ths, 11ths, and even 13ths), they often require more complex fingerings or the use of barre chords compared to the simpler open string options available in standard tuning. However, these alternative tunings are a treasure chest for musicians interested in generating complex chord structures. Consider the work of Joni Mitchell, whose intricate chord progressions showcase the beauty of open tunings.

The Challenge of Translating Open Chords to Standard Tuning

Most chord charts are created for standard tuning. Translating these charts to open tunings can be a daunting task for many guitarists, especially those who lack experience with chord composition. If you are familiar with standard tuning and find it comfortable, switching to open tunings might initially feel tiring and less intuitive.

Personal Preferences and Variations

If you find open tunings to your liking, there are some creative ways to enjoy them without sacrificing standard tuning proficiency. For instance, consider using a capo, positioning it on the 4th or 5th fret, and exploring finger-picking techniques. This approach strikes a balance between the advantages of open tunings and the comfort of standard tuning, making it an ideal method for those who want to experiment with different sounds while maintaining playing familiarity.

Furthermore, certain tunings below standard, such as DAD GAD or GGD BB, might sound a bit dull or less vibrant. This is why most guitarists tend to stick with standard or slightly adjusted tunings. Each tuning adds a unique flavor to your playing, but standard tuning remains a versatile and widely accepted standard for a reason.

Conclusion

The choice between standard tuning and open tunings ultimately depends on personal preference and musical style. While standard tuning offers a more straightforward and familiar experience, open tunings provide a wealth of opportunities for creating complex and unique chord progressions. Experimenting with both can expand your playing horizons and bring new dimensions to your guitar playing.