Is Music Created Around Lyrics or the Other Way Around: Creative Approaches of Songwriting
The age-old question of whether music should be crafted around lyrics or vice versa has sparked countless debates among songwriters and music enthusiasts alike. There is no one-size-fits-all answer, as the creative process varies greatly among individuals and even within the same artist across different songs. However, understanding the different approaches can help aspiring songwriters find their own unique routines and best practices.
Music or Lyrics First?
One of the most crucial considerations in songwriting is the sequence in which music and lyrics are developed. Writers with strong musical backgrounds might prefer to start with a melody, chord progression, or beat before considering the words. On the other hand, those with a knack for poetry might prefer to start with the lyrics and work backwards to create the accompanying music. There are many potential hybrid approaches as well, where songs begin with tentative lyrics or music, and evolve over time.
The question of prioritizing music or lyrics is not a new one. A blog post from a seasoned songwriter explores this topic, detailing their personal journey and multiple methods they have employed over time. For instance, the author initially wrote many songs by first setting a melody and then finding suitable lyrics to complement it. Later, they discovered that phrases or turns of phrase that caught their ear could inspire both musical and lyrical development. Additionally, at other times, the writing process centered around conveying a message or expressing a specific emotion, leading to the creation of lyrics and music aligned with these goals.
An Unauthorized Approach to Songwriting
Regardless of the starting point, the key takeaway is to start writing without waiting for inspiration. Successful songwriters often engage in free-form practices such as humming, making noise, or playing around with melodies until something interesting emerges. Once an inspired idea is born, it can serve as the foundation for building a song. It is essential to build and develop upon this initial spark to create cohesive music.
It is important for songwriters to recognize that their process is unique and can evolve over time. As the author mentions, they initially always started with music, then added lyrics and a title. However, their methods eventually shifted, allowing them to capture phrases or words that resonate with them, leading to the creation of music and lyrics in response.
Personal Experiences and Hybrid Methods
Many songwriters share that their approach to songwriting differs not only between songs but also between compositions by the same artist. One songwriter may consistently find that they build songs starting with a musical idea, while another might begin with a lyrical concept and then develop the music around it. Ultimately, the best way to create is to experiment with different techniques and find what works best for you.
The author emphasizes that, while they frequently start with music, they often allow lyrics and titles to develop organically as the song evolves. Occasionally, a lyrical line or musical idea will inspire the creation of the other, but the process is seldom a one-to-one exchange. Songwriters should be open to improvisation and evolve their methods periodically to keep their creative process fresh and exciting.
Conclusion and Inspiration
Ultimately, every songwriter has their own unique process that suits their creative nature. Whether you start with music or lyrics, the most important thing is to develop a routine that allows you to build and refine your songs effectively. Experiment with different approaches, and don't be discouraged if you find that what works for one song doesn't work for another. By embracing the variety and flexibility of the songwriting process, you can unleash your full creative potential and produce music that resonates with your listeners.
So, whether you're a seasoned songwriter or just starting out, take the time to explore your own creative process and find the approach that works best for you. Happy songwriting!