Is It Easier to Learn Drums, Piano, or Guitar/Bass?

The pursuit of playing a musical instrument can be both rewarding and challenging. However, many wonder which instrument is the easiest to learn among the drum set, piano, and guitar. In this article, we will explore the difficulties of learning these instruments and provide insights into why one might be easier or harder than the others.

The Reality of Learning the Guitar

The failure rate for aspiring guitarists is incredibly high, with over 90% failing to achieve the desired level of proficiency. This failure rate suggests that the guitar, despite its widespread popularity, is anything but easy to learn. Historically, the success rate is also unlikely to be much better for pianists and keyboard players, especially considering the numerous challenges they face. While electronic keyboards offer options such as single-finger chords and one-handed playing, these conveniences do not significantly ease the learning process. During the 1980s synth-pop era, multi-fingered keyboard players were the norm, and one-handed "keytar" players were more the exception. Very simple bass playing might be easier, but aspiring bassists usually aim to emulate virtuoso players like Paul McCartney, Gordon Sumner, Nick Beggs, and Mark King.

The Myth of the Easy Guitar

There is a common myth that the guitar is easy to learn. However, this misconception stems from the fact that many guitar players cannot actually play it like the masters. Artists such as Tommy Emmanuel, Martin Taylor, Frank Vignola, and their contemporaries are often the standard for true guitar proficiency.

While there are some talented metal players, the level of skill required to play like Steve Vai, Jon Jorgensen, or other virtuosos is truly extraordinary. It is not just about technique; it is about understanding music, melody, and harmony at a deep level. Learning to play the guitar, like any other instrument, requires significant effort and dedication.

Drums and the Basics of Music

Drums and percussion instruments are often perceived as easier to learn because they require a more limited knowledge of music theory. While drumming does not necessitate an understanding of melody and harmony in the same way that playing the piano or guitar does, rhythm is a fundamental aspect of music. Drums, in particular, involve mastering various rhythmic patterns and beats, which can be challenging but equally rewarding.

Moreover, learning to play the drums often starts with basic techniques such as proper grip, timing, and coordination. These fundamentals can be mastered relatively quickly, making drums a good entry point for beginners. However, as one progresses, the complexity and demands of drumming grow, especially when attempting to play advanced solos or complex rhythms.

Conclusion

Each musical instrument presents a unique set of challenges that must be overcome. The guitar, while widely believed to be easy, is a complex and demanding instrument that requires significant skill and dedication. Drums, while easier in terms of immediate technique acquisition, also demand a deep understanding of rhythm and timing. The piano offers a balance of technical and theoretical challenges, making it a versatile instrument for those willing to put in the time and effort.

Ultimately, the choice of which instrument to learn depends on personal interest, goals, and the level of commitment one is willing to make. Regardless of the choice, the journey to mastering an instrument is filled with challenges, but also with endless opportunities for growth and musical expression.