Exploring the Versatility of Vocals in Black Metal and Its Impact on the Genre
Black metal is a subgenre of extreme metal that emerged in the early 1980s, characterized by its high-effort production, raw and aggressive guitar work, and often cryptic and esoteric lyrical themes. However, within this relatively rigid structure, there exist numerous bands that push the boundaries of the genre by incorporating clean vocals or experimenting with different vocal styles. This article delves into the reasoning behind this trend and its impact on the black metal community.
The Evolution of Black Metal and Vocal Experimentation
From an outsider’s perspective, the inclusion of clean vocals in black metal or the experimentation with such styles might seem contradictory to the genre’s core principles. However, the history of black metal is rife with examples of bands redefining the genre’s boundaries. For instance, Cradle of Filth’s adoption of a more nuanced and melodic approach in their music challenged the stricter, more brutal norms of the genre.
Emperor, another seminal black metal band, paved the way for this kind of experimentation. Despite Emperor’s more elaborate and melodic music compared to many of their contemporaries, they managed to secure a place in the black metal canon. This shift was a result of several factors, including the evolving tastes of listeners and the changing dynamics within the genre.
The Influence of Market Dynamics and Fan Culture
The traditionalist view of black metal often hinges on the idea that only raw and unyielding forms of the genre should be considered legitimate. This view is often reinforced by gatekeepers and long-standing fan communities who prioritize adherence to the genre’s original ideals. However, as these gatekeepers aged, their influence waned. Prominent figures such as Euronymous of Mayhem and Varg Vikernes of Burzum became involved in controversial actions and legal troubles, distancing themselves from the genre they helped shape.
With the rise of new and more progressive voices, the black metal community became more accepting of musical diversity. This shift can be seen in the way Emperor’s fans and the broader metal community rallied behind the band’s changes. While some purists rejected these alterations, the wider acceptance of Emperor demonstrated the genre’s capacity to evolve while preserving its core identity.
Artistic Freedom and Rejection from Fan Communities
Bands like Krallice, an American black metal collective, often face rejection from the black metal community for their experimentation. Their artistry, which often blurs the lines between various metal subgenres, is seen by some as a betrayal of the genre’s strictures. Krallice’s integration of elements from seemingly disparate styles challenges the black metal community’s rigid boundaries, leading to their exclusion from the fold.
However, these rejections can also be seen as a form of respect. By highlighting the importance of sticking to the roots of black metal, these communities reinforce the genre’s identity. The tension between embracing innovation and maintaining tradition is a recurring theme in black metal.
The Importance of Authenticity and Personal Expression
Ultimately, the most compelling argument for the inclusion of clean vocals or experimental styles in black metal is the individual’s right to artistic expression. Musicians like Himmler (Isaak) from Emperor emphasize that the essence of black metal lies in creating music that is true to one’s personal vision. As Himmler puts it, 'I could make an album like Britney Spears and still be considered black metal,' demonstrating the mold-breaking potential of artists within the genre.
Similarly, the article’s author reflects on their own musical journey, stating that their preference for a hybrid of black metal, Neurosis, and Godflesh is wholly their own creation. This points to the importance of personal expression and individuality in creating meaningful and compelling music.
Conclusion
Black metal, like any subgenre, is continuously evolving. While some fans may resist this evolution, others see it as a natural progression of the genre. The inclusion of clean vocals or experimental elements can be seen as a sign of artistic freedom and a challenge to the genre's rigid boundaries. By prioritizing authenticity and personal expression, musicians can create a more diverse and vibrant black metal scene that continues to inspire and captivate listeners.