Every Musician Should Write Songs: Debunking the Myth

Is it essential for every musician to write their own songs? This age-old question has sparked numerous debates in the music community. Some believe that every musician must compose melodies and lyrics, while others argue that this skill is not universally applicable. In this article, we’ll explore this debate, discussing the uniqueness of musical and songwriting skills and the reasons why not every musician needs to be a songwriter.

Unique Skills of Songwriting

While it’s tempting to say that every musician should engage in songwriting, it’s important to recognize that writing songs involves distinct and complementary skills. Unlike virtuosos who master their instruments through rigorous practice, songwriting requires a different set of abilities, including creativity, lyricism, and composition. These skills are not always synonymous with musical proficiency or talent on an instrument.

No Universal Requirement

Not every musician has the inherent ability to compose melodies or write lyrics. This is not due to a lack of effort or talent but rather a difference in aptitude and interest. Eliminating classical musicians based on their inability to write songs would be a grave mistake. These musicians bring a unique richness to the musical world with their technical skills and interpretive talents.

Integrating Music and Songwriting

Just as some musicians find joy in playing music without writing their own songs, others derive immense satisfaction from both activities. Songwriting can enhance a musician's performance, offering new dimensions to their artistry. For example, when I embarked on my musical journey at 15, I was surprised to find that my fellow band members and the audience responded positively to the songs I penned. Since then, I’ve cultivated my songwriting while only moderately advancing my guitar skills. This dynamic balance allows individuals to focus on the aspects of music that they find most fulfilling.

Contrasting Artistic Pursuits

It’s also worth noting that not all successful musicians wish to engage in songwriting. My younger sister, a virtuoso cornet player and session musician, exemplifies this point. She excels in her specialized field of brass performance without ever needing to write music. Such specialization should be celebrated rather than criticized. Every musician, regardless of their chosen path, contributes valuable artistry to the world.

Conclusion: Embracing Diversity

In the vast and diverse world of music, it’s crucial to recognize that different skills and interests coexist. While some musicians thrive on songwriting, others excel in their instrumental prowess or ensemble playing. Instead of imposing a one-size-fits-all approach, we should encourage a rich tapestry of musical expression. Each musician’s unique contribution is valuable, and we should support and appreciate all forms of musical endeavors.

Keywords: musician, songwriter, music skills, musical endeavor, creativity