Elton John Albums Ranking: A Critical Analysis

The iconic singer-songwriter, Elton John, has crafted numerous albums throughout his illustrious career. From the 1970s to the present day, each album has its unique charm and appeal. In this article, we will take an in-depth look at the ranking of his albums from the 1970s onward. Our analysis will help you understand the evolution of Elton John's musical journey and his creative output during this period.

Albums from the 1970s

Elton John's career took off in the 1970s, a decade that saw him release several groundbreaking albums. Here is our ranking of his albums during this period:

1. Madman Across the Water (1977)

Rank: 1

Madman Across the Water is often considered one of Elton John's greatest albums. This album showcases his matured songwriting skills and a deeper emotional depth. The title track, along with songs like “Saturday Night’s Alright for Fighting,” distinguish it as a masterpiece in the rock genre.

2. Tumbleweed Connection (1975)

Rank: 2

Tumbleweed Connection comes in second for its innovative blend of classical and rock elements. The hit song “Tiny Dancer” is a standout, embodying the essence of 1970s pop. This album demonstrates Elton's ability to fuse different musical styles and create something entirely new.

3. Goodbye Yellow Brick Road (1973)

Rank: 3

Goodbye Yellow Brick Road is not only a classic but also a fan favorite. The album delves into more personal themes, reflecting on life's journey and emotional relationships. Songs like “Crocodile Rock” and “Too Little Too Late” perfectly capture the album's emotional depth.

4. Honky Chateau (1972)

Rank: 4

Honky Chateau stands out for its country and Western influence. The album’s simplicity and authenticity make it a standout in Elton's discography. “Friends in Low Places” and “square?

Mid-1970s and Beyond

While the early 1970s saw Elton at the top of his game, his creative spark began to wane during the mid-1970s. From this point onwards, the albums take a mixed stance in terms of quality and reception.

5. Captain Fantastic and the Brown Dirt Cowboy (1975)

Rank: 5

Captain Fantastic and the Brown Dirt Cowboy is a departure in style, featuring a more folk and country influence. Although the album received moderate success, it lacks the impactful singles found in later albums.

6. The Union (1992)

Rank: 6

The Union, a collaboration with k.d. lang, achieved a different kind of success. It received critical acclaim for its innovative nature and creative partnership. However, the tracks were more niche and limited in popularity.

7. Ghost Songs (2014)

Rank: 7

Ghost Songs sees Elton John revisiting and reworking classic tracks. While the remakes are respectful, they lack the originality and freshness of earlier work. The album won the Grammy for Best Compilation Soundtrack for Visual Media, showcasing Elton's enduring talent.

The Disappointments and Triumphs

Elton John released several albums that, while not as groundbreaking as his earlier work, still have their own merits. However, many of these albums are marred by lackluster performances and a number of forgettable tracks. Here are a few albums that fall under this category:

8. Dont Shoot Me, I’m Only the Piano Player (1970)

Rank: 8

Dont Shoot Me, I’m Only the Piano Player is the album where Elton John's fame truly began, but it fails to capture the later creativity and artistry. Though some tracks are memorable, the overall album is not as exceptional as the singer's subsequent work.

9. Blue Moves (1979)

Rank: 9

Blue Moves has a disappointing collection of songs. It lacks the energy and progressive feel of his earlier works, leaving it more as an enjoyable but forgettable addition to his discography.

10. Caribou (1982)

Rank: 10

Caribou saw Elton John trying to modernize his sound. However, the result was a less cohesive and less impactful album compared to his earlier work. While it still contains a few standout tracks, it does not live up to the expectations set by his earlier hit albums.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Elton John's albums from the 1970s continue to resonate with fans and music enthusiasts worldwide. While some albums are classics that stand the test of time, others are more forgettable due to a downturn in creativity and originality. For newcomers and longtime fans alike, revisiting these albums can offer a nostalgic journey through one of the greatest musicians of all time.

Recommendations for New Listeners

For new listeners, we recommend starting with his classics such as Goodbye Yellow Brick Road, Tumbleweed Connection, and Madman Across the Water. If you're seeking a broader compilation, we suggest Greatest Hits Volume 1 and exploring songs from the volumes that followed for additional gems. These selections will provide a solid foundation to appreciate Elton John's extensive and influential discography.