Do I Need to Learn the Acoustic Guitar First Before Electric?

For music lovers like you who have been captivated by the rebellious sound of AC/DC and Motley Crue since childhood and now aspire to play it, the idea of starting with an acoustic guitar before moving to an electric might feel like a necessary step. However, this belief is a long-standing myth that often hinders guitar beginners from exploring their true musical passions. As a seasoned guitarist, I would like to dispel this myth and provide insights on how to start your guitar journey without getting bogged down by outdated beliefs.

No, You Don’t Have to Start with an Acoustic Guitar

A common misconception is that beginners must start with an acoustic guitar before transitioning to an electric. This myth is rooted in historical practices and the belief that an acoustic guitar is easier to learn on due to its simpler construction. However, the reality is that playing the guitar is playing the guitar, regardless of the type. The only criteria for choosing a guitar should be your musical preferences and style.

The Classical Guitar vs. Universal Learning

Many guitar instructors prefer to start students with a classical guitar due to its intimate sound and the technique it helps develop. However, the true beauty of the guitar lies in its versatility. What you learn on a classical guitar can apply to any other type of guitar. Whether you want to play AC/DC, Motley Crue, or any other genre, you can start directly with an electric guitar and still develop the necessary skills and understanding.

Some tricks that apply to a classical guitar, such as tapping, may require amplification to be heard effectively. Additionally, certain techniques and sounds might benefit from the use of a pick or effects pedals. However, these are not prerequisites for learning the guitar and can be explored once you have a solid foundation.

Start with an Electric Guitar

The electric guitar is the instrument of choice for many aspiring guitarists, especially if they are inspired by rock and metal styles. Here are a few reasons why:

Self-Contained and Portable: Electric guitars can be played directly without the need for amplification. A simple headphone amplifier or a small practice amp can be enough to get you started. This makes it easier for beginners to practice without the need for a complex setup. No Rush for Expensive Gear: Until you know how to play the guitar, there's no rush to invest in a powerful and expensive amplifier or a plethora of effects pedals. Start with the basics and add to your setup as you improve and gain a better understanding of what you need. Distortion Does Not Make You a Good Player: While a distortion pedal can enhance your sound, it doesn't make you a better player. Focus on the fundamentals and develop your playing skills before you worry about fancy gear.

Your experience with the piano can be a significant advantage when learning the guitar. Understanding music theory and basic chord structures will make the transition smoother and more intuitive.

Both Ways Are Valid

There is no one-size-fits-all answer to whether you should start with an acoustic or an electric guitar. Many guitarists have successfully started with one and later moved to the other. I myself began with an acoustic guitar and appreciated its intimate sound and the way it made me feel the vibrations and the chord structures deeply. However, after a few years, I transitioned to an electric guitar and found that it offered a broader range in terms of physical ease, sound projection, and overall tonal possibilities.

Ultimately, the guitar is a powerful tool that allows you to express yourself in countless ways. Whether you choose to start with an acoustic or an electric, the journey of learning to play the guitar is full of discovery and joy. Embrace your musical journey, and don't let outdated myths dictate your path.