Drummer's Perspective on Click Track Preferences
As a drummer, the choice of click track in a recording or live performance can significantly impact the quality and feel of the music. Drummers often have different preferences based on the tempo, complexity, and genre of the music. In this article, we explore what kind of click track sounds prefer drummers and how they tailor these clicks to fit their needs. We also discuss the importance of tempo and the impact of click tracks in various musical styles.
Click Track Preferences Based on Tempo
Drums and rhythm are central to music, and click tracks play a crucial role in maintaining a consistent tempo. However, the specific choice of click track can vary widely among drummers depending on the tempo and complexity of the piece.
For mid-paced or faster songs, typically around 120 beats per minute (bpm), many drummers, including this author, prefer a straightforward four-quarter note click track. A click on the “one” gives a clear reference point, and the pro-tools “beep” click is acceptable for those who prefer a slightly different sound.
Slower Songs and Complex Rolls
When dealing with slower songs or complex rolls, as seen in prog-style music, a click track set to eighth or sixteenth notes can be beneficial. Doubling the clicks helps drummers maintain precision during long or intricate passages, preventing them from drifting off the grid. This technique ensures accurate timing and a smooth performance, particularly in demanding musical arrangements.
No Click Tracks for Jazz and Free Form Music
While precise timing is crucial for many genres, not all drummers rely on click tracks. For jazz and free-form music, where the tempo is often dynamic and changing, it is advisable to turn off click tracks and focus on the feel and organic flow of the music. These styles require a more flexible approach to timing, where the drummer has the freedom to push and pull the tempo, adding a unique character to the performance.
Click Track Challenges in Live Performances
The use of click tracks in live performances can pose several challenges. For instance, in a recent TV show house band gig, the music was programmed with a 8th note click, making it challenging to play with any feel against such a fast and dense click track. This experience highlights the importance of selecting a click track that complements the music rather than overwhelming it.
Optimal Click Sounding for Drummers
When it comes to the sound of the click track, drummers have their preferences. The ideal sound should not conflict with other elements like cymbals or bass drums. A mid-range sound without being too low or overpowering is preferred. Some drummers even opt for more creative solutions, such as blinking lights or tactile vibrations, provided they offer a clear reference point, especially for the “one” beat. The use of different sounds or intensities for the “one” can enhance the clarity and accuracy of the click track.
Adjusting Metronome Settings
While many drummers prefer the clarity provided by a consistent four-quarter note click, others may need more precision. In such cases, adjusting the metronome to eighth or sixteenth notes can ensure that each note is hit at the right moment. This level of precision is crucial for songs that demand high accuracy and technical skills, such as in electronic dance music (EDM) or complex contemporary compositions.
Ultimately, the choice of click track is a matter of personal preference and the requirements of the music. Drummers often experiment with different sounds and settings to find the perfect fit for their performance. Whether it's a straightforward click track, a precise metronome setting, or a more creative approach, the goal is to maintain the integrity of the music and enhance the overall performance.
By understanding the preferences and needs of drummers in relation to click tracks, producers, engineers, and musicians can create more seamless and successful musical productions. The right click track can mean the difference between a precise, controlled performance and a loose, unpredictable one. So, the next time you're preparing for a recording session or live performance, consider the drummer's perspective and select the click track that best suits the music and the drummer's needs.