Do Expensive Guitar Strings Really Make a Difference?
Understanding the Impact of String Quality on Your Sound
When it comes to guitar strings, the age-old question of whether more expensive options truly make a difference in sound and playability is often a matter of personal preference and budget. In this article, we will explore the impact of price on guitar strings and discuss the pros and cons of investing in higher-end options.
The Exception: Coated Strings and Their Benefits
One notable exception to general perceptions is the use of coated guitar strings. These strings often cost significantly more but last around 3-4 times longer than standard strings based on my extensive experience. While there is a slight decrease in brilliance, this is more noticeable on acoustic guitars compared to electric guitars. The trade-off is worth considering if you prioritize the convenience and longevity of your guitar setup.
Quality and Production Costs
Some premium strings, such as flat wound, monel tape wounds, and coated gypsy gut, are more expensive to produce. If you are paying for a quality that reflects these higher production costs, the answer will be more subjective. It is important to consider whether the slight increase in sound quality justifies the extra cost.
My Personal Experience with D'Addarrio XL Nickel Strings
For me, the answer has always been no. I prefer using moderately priced strings, specifically D'Addario XL Nickel strings, which are typically around $5 per pack in bulk. Regular string changes are crucial for maintaining optimal sound and playability. After the initial break-in period, new strings sound and feel fantastic, while old strings can lose elasticity, affecting the neck, and the equilibrium of the guitar. While this issue may not matter in the short term, over the long term, wood naturally deforms and warps, leading to potential problems.
Two Types of Expensive Strings to Consider
Coated Strings
Coated strings are designed to reduce corrosion caused by sweat and dirt. However, the trade-off is that they do not feel quite right. Despite their intended benefits, some users, including myself, prefer the natural feel of non-coated strings.
Boutique Strings
Boutique strings often cost 3 times as much as standard strings but may not have a clear and obvious reason for their higher price. For most players, especially those who change strings frequently, the cost seems unnecessary. While I am intrigued by these strings, my extensive collection of guitars makes their higher cost difficult to justify.
The Latest Pricing Trends
Currently, it seems that all types of guitar strings are pushing towards at least $10 per pack. The noticeable difference in sound quality between old and new strings can make it challenging to identify changes in sound without a controlled test setup using multiple guitars.
The Player's Role in Choosing Strings
Ultimately, the choice of strings is a decision made by the player on behalf of the guitar. What constitutes cheap versus expensive strings can vary greatly. Some consider premium strings to be a gimmick and recommend sticking with well-known brands like Ernie Ball for their quality and longevity.
Conclusion
The decision to invest in more expensive guitar strings is a personal one. If you prioritize longevity and convenience, coated strings might be the right choice. For most players, though, the cost may not justify the slight improvements in sound quality, especially when regular string changes are a necessity.