Do Bands or Artists Play Songs Demanded by Concertgoers?
The excitement and anticipation of a live concert often culminate in requests from the audience. Fans scream out song titles, hoping their favorites will be played. But can bands or artists truly play any song shouted at them during a show? This article explores the various factors that influence this decision, along with some real-world examples of artists accommodating requests.
Factors Influencing Performance Decisions
Several key factors come into play when deciding whether to include a fan-requested song in a concert setlist:
Setlist
Artists often have a predetermined setlist for their shows. Sticking to this plan helps maintain consistency and avoids potential disruptions. However, factors such as fan requests, song popularity, and artist spontaneity can sometimes influence changes to the setlist.
Popularity
If a fan requests a particularly popular or nostalgic song, the artist is more likely to acquiesce. Such songs generate positive energy and can lead to a memorable experience for the concertgoers. Bands and artists often want to cater to their audience's enjoyment, especially when it comes to chart-topping hits or fan favorites.
Spontaneity
The thrill of a live performance is partly in the unpredictability. Some artists thrive on the spontaneity of live shows and may be more inclined to play a fan-requested song on the spot. The crowd's energy and mood can propel an artist to take a risk and play a song they may not have considered initially.
Logistics
The complexity of a song or the need for specific instruments can also affect whether a requested song can be performed on stage. Simple covers or songs that require fewer instruments may be more feasible than complex arrangements or songs with unique requirements.
Examples of Fan Requests Being Accommodated
While many artists adhere to their setlists, there are instances where fan requests lead to spontaneous performances. Here are a few notable examples:
Del McCoury Band
The Del McCoury Band often plays fan requests after a few set pieces, reserving their biggest hit, "1952 Black Lightning," for the end of the show. This approach allows them to manage the crowd's engagement better and prolong the excitement of the performance.
Bob Dylan
Besides the Del McCoury Band, Bob Dylan is an exceptional case. He is known for his selective approach to fan requests, only playing them if the energy is right and the song fits the mood. While he does honor fan requests, he has a reputation for being cautious with his setlist.
The Bodeans
Among professional bands, The Bodeans stand out for their willingness to accommodate fan requests. On one occasion, the audience insisted on hearing a particular song, leading to a spontaneous performance that added an extra layer of excitement to the show. This willingness to be spontaneous sets them apart from other cover bands who typically stick to their rehearsed setlists.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while many bands and artists have a predetermined setlist for their shows, they often balance this with fan requests and the spontaneity of live performances. Factors such as song popularity, logistical considerations, and the energy of the crowd all play a role in deciding whether a requested song is played. The decision to accommodate fan requests can enhance the overall experience for concertgoers and create memorable moments that add to the allure of live music.