Comparing BTS and One Direction with Greek Golden Ratios: A Beauty Slice of Art

When it comes to assessing the appearance of K-pop idols and the #8220;handsome#8221; standards of Greek golden ratios, the #8220;Best Beauty Ratio Challenge#8221; becomes a fascinating topic. This article delves into a subjective analysis using a popular video channel, Photoshop Surgeon, which edits celebrity features to fit these classic aesthetic standards. We will break down the findings for each group and explore the implications of these ratios in the world of idol aesthetics.

Why White Standards Matter in the Golden Ratio Analysis

To start, it is important to acknowledge that the Greek Golden Ratios have been historically closely tied to European and particularly white Western beauty standards. This bias is often reflected in media and popular culture, where attributes deemed aesthetically pleasing are frequently associated with white individuals. Therefore, when examining the Golden Ratios, we must take into consideration the racial and cultural backgrounds of the individuals being analyzed.

One Direction: The Golden Ratio Champions

According to the Photoshop Surgeon channel, an impressive number of One Direction members align closely with the ideal Greek Golden Ratio. This makes One Direction unique among popular idol groups in terms of facial features that adhere to these standards.

Liam Payne

The most noticeable changes to Liam Payne were in his eyes. Despite this, his real features still pass the golden ratio test, showing a close fit.

Harry Styles

Harry Styles was once deemed one of the handsomest men due to his perfect golden ratio in his chin and eyes. However, the edited version changes the dynamic, suggesting that his real appearance is more appealing.

Louis Tomlinson

Although Louis Tomlinson’s picture in the video shows him scoring an impressive 84 on the golden ratio test, there isn’t an edited version available to compare. Nonetheless, it is clear that he is one of the closest to fitting the golden ratio among the two groups.

Niall Horan

Niall Horan does not have officially calculated golden ratio information, and no edited version exists from the Photoshop Surgeon channel. Therefore, it's challenging to make a direct comparison with the golden ratio.

Zayn Malik

Even though Zayn Malik is praised for his looks and is a non-white individual, his real features still align closely with the perfect golden ratio.

BTS: The Halfway Team

In contrast to One Direction, only a few members of BTS align with the golden ratio standards. This disparity highlights the significant cultural differences and the specific Western bias within these aesthetical standards.

Jin (Main Visual)

Jin, who is known for his eye-catching beauty, does indeed fit the golden ratio. However, his real features are more pleasing than the edited version, highlighting the westernization trend of the golden ratio.

Taehyung (V)

Although Taehyung fits the golden ratio from a side profile, theedited version further emphasizes the westernized features. This further demonstrates the challenges in adhering to strict golden ratio standards.

Beauty is Subjective, and Standards are Fluid

While the Greek Golden Ratio can provide some insight into facial aesthetics, it is crucial to recognize the subjectivity of beauty. Cultural and personal preferences play a significant role in shaping what is considered attractive. The golden ratio, rooted in Western beauty standards, may not apply to many non-white individuals. This does not mean that BTS members or any other non-white individuals are less attractive; it simply reflects the biases and limitations of the golden ratio as a universal standard.

Supporting BTS and One Direction, both groups have unique features that make them appealing to their respective fan bases. Whether it's the harmonious golden ratio or the vibrant energy that these idol groups bring to their music and performances, their achievements and success are worth celebrating.

Conclusion

From a golden ratio perspective, One Direction members exhibit a higher alignment with these classic Western beauty standards, with at least three members fitting the criteria. BTS, on the other hand, has a more varied alignment, with only two members fitting the ideal ratio. However, this analysis must be taken in the context of cultural biases and the limits of the golden ratio as a universal standard.

Ultimately, beauty remains a subjective experience, and it is essential to support and appreciate the unique qualities and aesthetics of artists, regardless of the specific facial standards they meet.