Buddy Holly, The Beatles, and The Rolling Stones: A Debate on Their Greatest Hits
When it comes to the greats of rock and roll, names like Buddy Holly, The Beatles, and The Rolling Stones immediately come to mind. Each band left an indelible mark on music history, and their songs have resonated through various generations. Let's delve into a detailed exploration of what might be considered the best song by each of these iconic bands, with a special focus on one quintessential track by Buddy Holly: 'That'll Be the Day'.
That'll Be the Day: Buddy Holly's Upbeat Rocker
The energy and spirit of 'That'll Be the Day' by Buddy Holly is simply unmatched. Recorded in 1957 as part of The Crickets and later inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame, this song isn't just a rock 'n' roll classic; it's a testament to the genre's most vital period. The phrase 'That'll Be the Day' itself is said to have originated from a line in a John Wayne movie, adding an extra layer of cultural reference to the song.
Various artists have covered this song over the years, each bringing their unique style and interpretation. A notable version was done by Pure Prairie League, while Linda Ronstadt included it on her Grammy-winning album 'Hasten Down the Wind'. It's also worth noting that The Quarrymen, the band that would eventually become The Beatles, recorded this song.
Wishing by The Beatles
The Beatles launched their successful career with a song titled 'Wishing' that appeared on the flip side of another hit, 'That'll Be the Day'. Originally recorded as a cover of Chuck Berry's 'Brown Eyed Handsome Man', it was reworked and renamed 'I'm Gonna Love You Too'. This track, written by Joe B. Mauldin, sits perfectly among the band's early discography, showcasing their talent even in the early days of their career.
Another prominent song by The Beatles from 1959 is 'It Doesn't Matter Anymore'. This song, written by Buddy Holly collaborator Norman Petty, is a poignant reflection of heartache and resilience. It highlights the band's ability to touch on human emotions beyond just the upbeat, whimsical side of rock 'n' roll that they were known for.
The Rolling Stones and Their Heartbeat
The Rolling Stones, known for their raw and intense energy, have many hits in their catalog. However, one standout track that deserves mention is 'Heartbeat'. Written by producer Norman Petty and Holly collaborator Bob Montgomery, this song's raw emotion and tight rhythm give it a unique appeal that resonates with many listeners. The Stones' performance of this song is infused with the grit and intensity that made them one of the most influential bands of all time.
Conclusion: The Debate
When debating the best song by these legendary artists, it's clear that each has their crowning moments. Buddy Holly's 'That'll Be the Day' is an absolute must-listen for anyone fond of rock 'n' roll. The Beatles' 'Wishing' and 'It Doesn't Matter Anymore' showcase their range and emotional depth, while The Rolling Stones' 'Heartbeat' is a testament to their raw and powerful sound.