Why Can't Blackpink Members Sing Live?

The question of whether Blackpink can effectively perform live and sing has been a topic of much discussion among fans. Opinions are divided, and many arguments have been put forward on both sides. Some believe that, although they can sing to some extent, further training in vocal techniques is necessary. Others assert that the band does possess the ability to sing live, albeit with some occasional lapses.

Arguments Against Blackpink's Live Singing Capabilities

Opponents of the band's live performance often cite several reasons for their belief that Blackpink needs improvement. First, the concern is about the quantity of their repertoire. It is argued that they only have a limited number of songs, which makes it difficult for them to perform lengthy live sets. This limitation can lead to a lack of pacing and variety, both of which are crucial for a successful live performance.

Another argument is that Blackpink members should focus more on vocal training to improve their delivery. Some opinions suggest that during live performances, the vocal quality often sounds forced or shouts, especially during rapped sections. This is not only a matter of style but also affects the overall impact of their performances. The argument here is that with more practice, their vocal skills could significantly improve, enhancing the authenticity and emotional depth of their live shows.

Supporting the Idea of Good Live Singing

Proponents of Blackpink's live performance argue that such criticisms may be unfounded. They point out that every live performance comes with its own challenges, and it would be unfair to assume that Blackpink is unable to sing based on certain off days. Moreover, dance and physical movement, particularly jumping, can indeed affect the quality of a singer's voice, but this does not necessarily mean that the band lacks singing ability. Fans often argue that the members are inconsistently praised for their dancing and choreography, so why not trust their singing abilities as well?

The Role of Health and Talent in Live Performance

Around the discussions, health and weight factors are also brought into play. Some speculate that members might be underweight, which can result in health and stamina problems, both of which could impact their live performances. Additionally, there is a belief that the agency or management might have prioritized visual aesthetics over vocal talent, although this is often disputed.

Another argument is that some members might not be 'natural' singers and may rely heavily on autotune and other vocal tools to maintain consistency during live performances. However, this technology can only bridge a gap rather than improve actual skill levels, which is a point of contention in the debate.

Conclusion

Considering the range of opinions and arguments, it seems that the issue of Blackpink's vocal performance in live settings is multifaceted. While vocal improvement and expanded repertoire are certainly areas for development, the band has also shown that they can perform live and sing well. The key is to understand that live performances are not infallible and that the quality of a live show can vary on any given day. Patience and a more nuanced perspective can help in appreciating the talent showcased by each member of Blackpink in their live performances.