What Song Has Good Lyrics but Has a Bad Beat?

In the world of music, an artist’s creative vision often extends beyond just the rhythm and beat of a song. While a strong beat can certainly elevate a track, there are instances when musicians choose to prioritize the lyrical content, leaving the beat to be appreciated, or even challenged, on its own merits.

Creator Destroyer by Angel Olsen

Angel Olsen’s “Creator Destroyer” is a notable example. While the song possesses powerful and thought-provoking lyrics, its rhythm does not quite match the high standards of modern pop or even the dance music of the Big Band Era. Despite this, it stands out in a batch of around 50 Tin Pan Alley ‘standards’ that similarly boast strong lyricism but lack a solid beat by contemporary measures.

Standards and Their Potential

Many songs from the Golden Age of Tin Pan Alley, like “Standards,” were originally written for Broadway shows. These compositions oftenhad strong and evocative lyrics that spoke to a specific era and audience. However, when these songs are compared to modern forms like Rock and Roll, RB, or Blues, their beats can appear dated or weak. Yet, their enduring appeal lies in the quality of their lyrics, which continue to resonate today.

Resurrecting Olde Beasts

Interestingly, there are instances where old songs find new life. A notable example is the song “The More I See You,” which was released in 1945 but lacked a beat that resonated for a decade or more. It wasn't until jazz musicians took it up that the song began to gain traction again, eventually becoming more popular and influential.

Similarly, creators like Neil Young might have strong lyrics but are sometimes dismissed due to their distinct vocal style. Young’s songs, like “Rent in Araby,” possess profound lyrics but the beat can be straightforward, sometimes making casual listeners overlook the depth of the song.

Progressive Rock Insights

On the other hand, certain artists in genres like Progressive Rock have refined the art of changing the beat within a song, creating a dynamic listening experience. They often rely on outstanding drummers who innovate and adapt, contributing to the song's overall impact. Songs that change the beat frequently, like those found in Progressive Rock, can provide a more engaging and varied listening experience.

Modern Discoveries

It’s not uncommon for modern artists to be dismissed as “shitty pop” until one delves into their lyrical content. Artists like Childish Gambino and Tyler, The Creator are prime examples. Their beats might not always live up to the highest standards, but their lyrics offer depth, complexity, and often deal with significant social issues. It’s these introspective and meaningful words that can transform a lackluster beat into an engaging and thought-provoking musical experience.

In conclusion, while a strong beat is certainly an essential component of a song, it’s not the only aspect that matters. Sometimes, the lyrics can carry a song far beyond its rhythmic limitations, allowing both the casual and the discerning listener to connect with a piece of music on a deeper level.

Final Thoughts

Music is a subjective art form, and each listener brings their unique perspective to the table. Whether it’s the lyrical depth of songs like “Creator Destroyer” or the often-changing beats in Progressive Rock, there isalways a story to be told through music, and sometimes that story lies in the words.