Introduction

Despite his widespread admiration and enduring legacy, there are indeed individuals who find little to no charm in the works of the genius, Ludwig van Beethoven. In this article, I explore the reasons behind my particular disdain for this iconic figure in classical music, touching on both the positive and negative facets of his artistry.

Why I Love Beethoven

Before diving into my negative impressions, it is essential to acknowledge the myriad reasons why Beethoven is celebrated. He is indeed capable of composing some of the most beautiful passages, especially in the realm of piano music. Beethoven's compositions showcase profound emotions, ranging from great joy to deep sorrow, and even the most transcendent magical moments. His music has the power to evoke feelings of joy, sorrow, and a sense of wonder, captivating audiences and listeners alike. For instance, when Beethoven's music captures you in a whirlwind of dance or lifts your gaze to the heavens, it is difficult to resist his charm.

Why I Don't Particularly Admire Him

However, despite these merits, Beethoven's music also evokes some negative emotions and reactions. The spirit of his music can be strident, bombastic, and even boastful, at times resembling a show-off personality. This can manifest in his compositions and leave listeners feeling as though things have been done to them. Additionally, his use of nationalism, particularly in the triumphalism and militaristic themes, can be off-putting to some. Beethoven's music at times sounds as though it is composed for celebratory moments after a victory, creating a sense of grandeur and glory that can alienate listeners who prefer more understated compositions.

Comparison with Other Composers

While Beethoven is undoubtedly a towering figure in the classical music world, I find myself more inclined towards the gentle compositions of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. Although Mozart's music can sometimes feel repetitive, with its endless sawing and repetition, there remains a timeless quality to his works that resonates deeply. However, it is worth noting that even Shaw, a great admirer of both Wagner and Beethoven, conceded to Beethoven's superiority in certain respects.

The Influence of Personal Experience

My relationship with Beethoven began at a young age, when my father played his Fifth Symphony to keep me occupied while I was ill. At the tender age of three, almost seven decades ago, this exposure planted the seeds of my understanding and appreciation for classical music. As I grew, my love for music deepened, and I immersed myself in various genres. It was not until my more recent years that I began to grasp the broader impact and significance of Beethoven's contributions. Tyler Fara's eloquent explanations highlight how Beethoven's compositions parallel the structure of modern music, with a repetitive, catchy hook and distinct sections that create familiar and appealing patterns.

Conclusion

While Beethoven is undoubtedly a pivotal figure in the world of classical music, my personal response to his works is mixed. His music can invoke powerful emotions, but it can also leave me feeling that my feelings are being manipulated. In contrast, composers like Bach and Vivaldi, with their profound intellect and beautiful spirit, resonate more with my personal tastes. Ultimately, the enjoyment of music is a highly personal and subjective experience, and what touches one person's soul may not do the same for another.