Why do People Criticize Paul McCartney for Writing the Lyric “The Movement You Need Is on Your Shoulder”?

Paul McCartney, a legendary member of The Beatles, has faced some criticism for the lyrics in his song 'The Long and Winding Road.' One of the most notable lines that has sparked controversy is 'the movement you need is on your shoulder.' Despite some listeners finding the lyric vague and open to multiple interpretations, others argue that it adds a layer of depth and poetic quality to the song. Let’s delve into the various perspectives and reasons behind the criticism of this line.

The Criticism of Simplicity and Vagueness

Paul himself expressed dissatisfaction with the line, feeling that it didn’t make much sense and seemed redundant after using the word “shoulder” in an earlier verse. However, it was John Lennon who convinced McCartney that it was a poetic way to convey that the next good thing or right decision is just within reach but right there. Many critics argue that the line is somewhat vague and open to multiple interpretations, which can detract from its impact and meaning.

Poetic Ambiguity vs. Misunderstanding

Some listeners find the lyric ambiguous and open to interpretation, which has led to criticism. Critics argue that the subtle and evocative nature of the word "shoulder" might make it difficult for certain listeners to grasp the intended meaning. The lyric can be seen as inherently vague, which some may find less impactful or meaningful than more straightforward expressions.

The Context in the Song and Overall Impact

In the broader context of the song, which reflects on themes of perception, wisdom, and optimism, some critics feel that the lyric does not contribute effectively to the overall message or tone. The song as a whole is a poignant reflection on the impermanence of life and the struggles of feeling lost. The phrase "the movement you need is on your shoulder" may be seen as somewhat out of place within this context, detracting from the otherwise cohesive and powerful message.

Comparisons to Other Works

Paul McCartney, as a member of The Beatles, is often held to a high standard in terms of lyrical quality. Some critics compare his solo works to the more profound and experimental lyrics of John Lennon and other contemporaries such as Steely Dan’s Donald Fagen and Walter Becker, and Paul Simon. McCartney’s solo works are sometimes perceived as simpler and less experimental, which has led to criticism.

The Criticism of 'Performing with'

Another line in the song, "You're waiting for someone to perform with," has also been criticized for being out of place. While McCartney seems to have been stuck in finding a suitable rhyme, the overall impact of the song is still widely appreciated. The line is just one aspect of a much larger and more impactful composition. The song as a whole is often praised for its poetic quality and its ability to provoke thought about the human condition.

Conclusion

While the criticism of 'the movement you need is on your shoulder' in 'The Long and Winding Road' is valid, it is important to consider the broader impact and the overall emotional journey the song intends to convey. The line, while not perfect, contributes to the rich tapestry of the song's lyrics. McCartney's work, like any other artist's, is subjective and open to interpretation. Whether one appreciates the ambiguity and poetic quality or finds the lyrics lacking, it is clear that 'The Long and Winding Road' remains a testament to the power of McCartney's songwriting.