Analysis of 'This is America' and Its Grammy Win: Is Hip-Hop Truly Appreciated by The Grammy Awards?
Centuries of rich history in the hip-hop community culminated in a controversial victory at the 2019 Grammy Awards. 'This is America' by Kendrick Lamar, featured in the collaborative piece 'Spirit,' took home Song of the Year and Record of the Year, causing both widespread admiration and skepticism. While some argue that the song indeed deserves its accolades, others view it as a fluke or a misfit in the genre's recognition. This article delves into the nuances of 'This is America,' examining its impact, the songwriting, and the broader context of the Grammy Awards' perspective on hip-hop.
Introduction to the Controversy
'This is America' dropped as a single without much fanfare. It was essentially a song amongst many in the hip-hop genre, until the video's release. The video, which is what made the song truly special, sparked a mix of reactions. While some praised its daring and thought-provoking content, others criticized it as a bastardization of the genre, contributing to an ongoing debate over what truly defines hip-hop and whether it is adequately recognized by the Grammy Awards.
The Grammy Awards: Hip-Hop's Heavy Portfolio
The Grammy Awards have a complex relationship with hip-hop. Over the years, the genre has established a robust presence in the awards, reflecting its multifaceted nature. However, the 2019 Grammy Awards saw 'This is America' win multiple categories, leading to questions about the criteria and standards used for selecting the winners. Some argue that the Grammy Awards have a mundane understanding of what constitutes hip-hop, which might have led to an overestimation of 'This is America's' impact and play value.
Alternatives and Comparisons
A notable alternative that didn't win but arguably deserves recognition is Drake's song 'God's Plan.' The song went 8x platinum and had universal replay value alongside a popular music video that resonated with a broader audience. Drake's song demonstrates a different kind of artistic and commercial success that might better fit the Grammy Awards' standards. Critics suggest that if 'This is America' won, perhaps 'God's Plan' should have been the one in consideration, hinting at a broader issue with the Grammy's selection process.
Subjectivity and Artistic Merit
The debate over 'This is America' also touches on the subjectivity of art and music. In an ideal world, music would be judged purely on its artistic merit. However, real-world perception is always tinted with personal bias and cultural context. Some argue that 'This is America' was a daring, provocative song that addressed pressing issues, making it a deserving win. Others see it as a niche piece that failed to capture the essence of mainstream hip-hop culture. This suggests a gap between the awards' vision and the public's understanding of the genre.
Conclusion: The Road Ahead for Hip-Hop at the Grammys
The Grammy Awards' recognition of 'This is America' raises questions about the industry's evolving understanding of hip-hop. While 'This is America' won its awards with critical acclaim, it also sparked debates about the genre's recognition. The continuing push for more diverse and representative categories in the Grammys opens up new avenues for authentic hip-hop content to be recognized. The debate is an opportunity for the industry to reflect and improve, ensuring that hip-hop continues to thrive and be appreciated on a global stage.